Your worldwide refrigerant partner

Get in touch with us

Freight Market Discipline: Lessons from the Q1 2026 TD Cowen/AFS Index

Author
Ryan Rudman
Publication Date
April 7, 2026

The global logistics and transportation sector in the first quarter of 2026 presents a significant paradox for industrial stakeholders and supply chain managers. While manufacturing activity across major Western economies has entered its tenth consecutive month of contraction, freight rates for critical shipping modes have remained at historic, record-high levels. This phenomenon is best captured in the Q1 2026 release of the TD Cowen/AFS Freight Index, a comprehensive data snapshot that provides predictive pricing for truckload, less-than-truckload (LTL), and parcel transportation markets. For industries that rely on the physical movement of bulky or hazardous goods, such as the specialized refrigerant and cooling sectors, these findings are more than just statistical anomalies. They represent a fundamental shift in how carrier pricing power is wielded in a "low-demand, high-discipline" environment.

The findings from the first three months of 2026 suggest that the era of "buying volume" through pricing concessions has effectively ended. Major carriers are now utilizing sophisticated revenue management and network efficiency strategies to protect their margins, even as total tonnage fluctuates. For companies like AFS Cooling, which manages the complex logistics of global hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) distribution, understanding these freight dynamics is essential for maintaining cost-effective supply chains in a post-HFC economy.

The Less-Than-Truckload (LTL) Record: A Study in Pricing Power

The most remarkable development in the Q1 2026 freight landscape is the continued strength of the Less-Than-Truckload (LTL) market. According to the latest index data, LTL cost per shipment has remained more than 40 percent above January 2018 levels since the second quarter of 2022. This is a staggering statistic when considered alongside the fact that the average weight per shipment has declined by 20 percent over the same interval. Traditionally, a significant drop in shipment weight would lead to a corresponding softening in rates as carriers compete for lighter loads to fill capacity. However, the first quarter of 2026 has proven that traditional market logic no longer applies.

The LTL rate per pound index reached a new record high in late 2025, coming in at 67.9 percent above the January 2018 baseline. While the index is projected to see a slight 1 percent quarterly decline in Q1 2026 to reach 66.1 percent, this still represents the ninth consecutive quarter of year-over-year growth. Mich Fabriga, the Vice President of LTL Pricing at AFS Logistics, notes that this is a testament to the exceptional pricing discipline maintained by major carriers. These carriers have resisted the urge to concede on price to capture volume, focusing instead on internal network optimization and advanced revenue management. For shippers, this means that understanding how their specific freight fits into a carrier’s "network puzzle" is now the most important factor in optimizing freight spend.

This LTL strength is particularly relevant for the cooling and HVACR industry. Refrigerant gases are typically shipped in specialized cylinders or industrial drums that do not always fill an entire truck, making them prime candidates for LTL shipping. As carriers prioritize efficiency, the "hazardous" and "bulky" nature of refrigerant shipments can lead to significant accessorial charges and higher base rates unless managed by experts who understand carrier network preferences.

The Truckload Market: A Fragile Recovery in the Making

While the LTL sector remains a fortress of pricing power, the truckload market in Q1 2026 is showing signs of a "fragile recovery." After enduring nearly three years of rock-bottom rates, carriers are beginning to see the first glimpses of a market turnaround. The truckload rate per mile index for Q4 2025 reached 7.6 percent above the January 2018 baseline, marking the first time the index has surpassed the 7 percent threshold since the first quarter of 2023.

Aaron LaGanke, the Vice President of Freight Services at AFS Logistics, suggests that those carriers who have successfully weathered the downturn may soon be rewarded. Several supply-side factors are currently exerting downward pressure on total capacity, which naturally supports higher rates. These factors include:

1. Strategic Carrier Exits: Thousands of smaller operators have exited the market over the last 24 months due to unsustainable operating costs.

2. Industry Consolidation: Major players are acquiring smaller competitors to streamline their footprints and eliminate excess capacity.

3. Regulatory Enforcement: Stricter enforcement of Commercial Driver’s License (CDL) requirements and language proficiency standards has further constrained the pool of available drivers.

Despite these supply-side contractions, the demand side of the equation remains subdued. The American Trucking Associations (ATA) Truck Tonnage Index rose only 0.2 percent in late 2025, following multiple months of more significant declines. The truckload rate per mile index is expected to stay relatively flat in Q1 2026, reaching 7.4 percent above the baseline, which represents a 1.1 percent increase over the previous year. For shippers of industrial commodities, this suggests that while the "panic pricing" of the early 2020s has subsided, the floor for truckload rates has effectively been reset at a higher level.

Parcel Shipping and the Impact of Market Share

The parcel market in early 2026 mirrors the LTL sector in its display of pricing discipline. Record high rates in the parcel segment show that major carriers are successfully wielding their market share to shape the environment in their favor. Even as e-commerce growth rates have stabilized, carriers have been able to implement and maintain "peak season" surcharges and general rate increases (GRIs) with high levels of consistency.

This is a critical factor for the maintenance and service side of the HVACR industry. While bulk refrigerants move via LTL or truckload, critical spare parts, sensors, and specialized tools often move through parcel networks. The continued "pricing strength" of parcel carriers means that the "last-mile" cost of HVACR service remains a significant portion of a contractor’s total overhead. In January 2026 alone, several major HVACR parts and tool manufacturers implemented price increases of 1 to 10 percent, often citing increased "manufacturing and logistics inputs" as the primary drivers.

The Manufacturing Contraction and the Logistics Gap

One of the most concerning findings in the Q1 2026 research is the growing gap between the health of the manufacturing sector and the cost of logistics. United States manufacturing activity has contracted for ten consecutive months, yet freight spend across almost all modes remains elevated. This suggests that the cost of moving goods is no longer as tightly coupled to the volume of goods being produced as it once was.

This "decoupling" is driven by the increasing complexity of modern supply chains. Carriers are facing higher costs for labor, insurance, and the transition to cleaner vehicle fleets, which they are passing on to shippers through more sophisticated pricing models. For a business producing industrial equipment or refrigerants, this means that the "logistics component" of the total cost of goods sold (COGS) is becoming more volatile and harder to predict. As Mich Fabriga points out, shippers must now find savings through "mode optimization"—the process of carefully selecting between parcel, LTL, and truckload based on real-time network data—rather than simply negotiating for lower base rates.

Tie-Back: AFS Cooling and Strategic Supply Chain Orchestration

In this landscape of "exceptional pricing discipline" and historic freight records, the role of a specialized partner like AFS Cooling has never been more vital. AFS Cooling is a subsidiary of the Amsterdam-based AFS Group, a firm that has provided multi-asset intermediary services for over 175 years. While AFS Logistics (the source of the freight index) is a distinct entity often associated with the group’s broader supply chain intelligence, AFS Cooling utilizes this high-level market data to protect its clients from the volatility of the refrigerant trade.

AFS Cooling assists its clients by serving as a comprehensive "one stop shop" for refrigerant needs, combining regulatory expertise with physical logistics management. In the first quarter of 2026, the firm’s ability to orchestrate the "physical" side of the HFC trade is as important as its ability to manage "environmental" quotas.

How AFS Cooling Assists Clients with Freight and Logistics:

1. End-to-End Supply Chain Management: AFS Cooling coordinates every step of the order process, from placement at a global manufacturer to final delivery at a client’s facility. By taking care of the logistics and organizing the "seamless transportation of goods," they allow their clients to focus on their core HVACR operations.

2. Cost-Effective Shipping Solutions: Leveraging the broader market intelligence of the AFS network, AFS Cooling selects the "most suitable and cost-effective shipping methods" for bulky gas cylinders. This includes navigating the LTL network puzzle to avoid the record-high rate per pound premiums that unmanaged shippers often face.

3. Importer of Record Services: As a trusted global importer, AFS Cooling assumes the legal and administrative responsibility for the shipment. This includes managing all customs documentation, import permits, and certificates of origin, ensuring a smooth workflow that avoids the "costly errors" or customs delays that can arise in a constrained freight environment.

4. Strategic Procurement and Inventory: By understanding the "fragile recovery" of the truckload market and the "supply rigidity" of the refrigerant sector, AFS Cooling advises clients on the optimal timing for bulk purchases. This allows businesses to build strategic inventories before peak-season freight surcharges and refrigerant price hikes take effect.

5. Risk Mitigation: The firm’s "rigorous legal checks" and adherence to international trade laws protect clients from the reputational and financial risks of illegal trade or non-compliant shipping practices. In a year where the EPA and EU are increasing their "administrative consequences" for non-compliance, this professional oversight is an essential insurance policy.

The Outlook for the Remainder of 2026

As we look toward the second and third quarters of 2026, the logistics market is expected to remain in a state of "disciplined tension." While a full demand-side spark to ignite a total recovery has yet to materialize, the supply-side contractions in the truckload and LTL sectors are likely to keep rates floor-supported. Shippers should anticipate continued year-over-year growth in LTL rates and a gradual "inching up" of truckload spot market rates toward contract levels.

For the cooling industry, this means that the transition to low-GWP refrigerants and A2L equipment will occur in a high-cost logistics environment. The "refrigerant transition" itself is already creating its own bottlenecks, with R-454B prices running significantly above legacy levels and new equipment requiring specialized tools and handling. When combined with record freight rates, the total cost of an HVACR project in 2026 is significantly higher than it was just a few years ago.

Conclusion: Data as the New Moat

The Q1 2026 TD Cowen/AFS Freight Index provides a clear warning for any business that still treats logistics as a "passive" expense. In an era where carriers use advanced analytics to maximize every cent of revenue per pound, shippers must respond with equal levels of sophistication. Success in 2026 requires more than just a good product; it requires a "disciplined" approach to every mile of the supply chain.

For the clients of AFS Cooling, this discipline is built into the partnership. By leveraging the deep market expertise and "entrepreneurial spirit" of the AFS Group, these businesses can navigate the dual challenges of "regulated scarcity" in the HFC market and "disciplined pricing" in the freight market. Whether it is through mode optimization, strategic quota management, or expert "importer of record" services, AFS Cooling ensures that its clients are "always on the ball" in a rapidly changing world. As the industry moves into the peak demand months of 2026, the ability to move goods with "integrity, accuracy, and efficiency" will be the primary engine of commercial success.